We sub out part of our scope. What does the “your work” exclusion, and endorsement CG 22 94, mean for us?
By Siddansh Bohra, CEO, Rayon · Last reviewed
Exclusion l of CG 00 01 removes property damage to your own completed work, but it does not apply if the damaged work, or the work that caused the damage, was performed for you by a subcontractor. Endorsement CG 22 94 deletes that exception. With it on your policy, damage to your completed work is excluded whether your own crew or your sub did the work.
Want this checked on your own certificates? Bring 50 you have already sent and keep the findings. Book a walkthrough
What does exclusion l say?
The exclusion is two sentences. The first removes “‘Property damage’ to ‘your work’ arising out of it or any part of it and included in the ‘products-completed operations hazard’.” The second gives part of it back: “This exclusion does not apply if the damaged work or the work out of which the damage arises was performed on your behalf by a subcontractor.” [1]
Two definitions carry the weight. “Your work” means work or operations performed by you or on your behalf, plus the materials, parts and equipment furnished with it. So for this purpose a subcontractor’s work is your work. The products-completed operations hazard covers damage that happens away from your premises after the work is completed, and the form treats work as completed when the contract is finished or when that part has been put to its intended use [1].
The exclusion therefore applies after completion. Damage while the job is still in progress is dealt with by a different exclusion, j, which removes damage to the particular part you are working on [1]. On the property side, the cost of redoing defective work is the subject of builder’s risk, rework and the LEG 2 and LEG 3 clauses.
What does CG 22 94 change?
| After completion | CG 00 01 as written | With CG 22 94 10 01 |
|---|---|---|
| Your own crew’s defective work damages other work your crew did | Excluded | Excluded |
| Your subcontractor’s defective work damages work your crew did | Exception applies: not excluded by l | Excluded |
| Your crew’s defective work damages work your subcontractor did | Exception applies: not excluded by l | Excluded |
| Your work damages property that is not part of your scope | Not within exclusion l | Not within exclusion l |
Why does this matter to a trade contractor?
The exception is usually discussed for general contractors, because nearly everything a general contractor delivers is built by subcontractors. Attorney Mark Malloy notes that for a general contractor the “work” is arguably the entire project, so removing the exception can leave almost no completed operations property damage coverage [3]. He cites Builders Mutual Insurance Co. v. Kalman, a 2009 federal district court decision in South Carolina. The court described itself as apparently the first nationwide to analyze CG 22 94 10 01, and held that with the subcontractor exception removed, the exclusion barred coverage for a general contractor’s defect claim [3].
The same logic runs one tier down. A mechanical contractor that subs out insulation, controls or water treatment, or an electrical contractor that subs out fire-stopping or fiber, has a scope made partly of other firms’ work. The exposures of each are set out in the insurance problem specific to each trade on a data-center job. Writing for the San Diego County Bar Association, Danielle Ward notes that CG 22 94 on a subcontractor’s policy also precludes coverage where that subcontractor subbed out its work to another contractor [4].
Without the endorsement, a failure in the sub-tier’s work that damages the rest of your completed system is not caught by exclusion l. With it, that damage is excluded.
Does the exception guarantee coverage?
No. An exception to an exclusion does not create coverage. The claim still has to be property damage caused by an occurrence, and no other exclusion may apply. A claim with no physical damage is examined in who pays when a commissioning test fails and nothing is damaged. Malloy summarizes the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s reasoning in American Family v. American Girl in those terms: the subcontractor exception does not create new coverage, it restores coverage that the exclusion would otherwise remove [3].
Whether a particular defect claim meets those tests is a question for coverage counsel in the project’s state.
- Look in the forms schedule for CG 22 94 [2], for CG 22 95, which Malloy and Ward describe as the project-specific version [3] [4], or for an insurer form with “subcontractor” and “your work” in the title. Gary Grindle notes in Insurance Journal that a carrier’s equivalent endorsement can eliminate the exception in the same way as CG 22 94 [6].
- An answer in Independent Agent magazine notes that some insurers remove the exception with their own wording and then offer a buy-back, which is not always as broad as the original [5].
- Check what your subcontract promises upstream, in particular any requirement for completed operations coverage or any bar on non-standard exclusions. Completed operations claims from every job share one aggregate, as the per-project aggregate and CG 25 03 explains.
- Check your own sub-tier agreements for additional insured status and limits, since their policies become the first source of recovery if yours excludes the loss. The wording of that status depends on the edition, covered in why contracts ask for CG 20 10 11 85.
Sources
- ISO CG 00 01 04 13, Commercial General Liability Coverage Form
- ISO CG 22 94 10 01, Exclusion: Damage To Work Performed By Subcontractors On Your Behalf (form text not fetched)
- Mark D. Malloy, Meissner Tierney Fisher & Nichols, Coming Full Circle? The Elimination of the Subcontractor Exception
- Danielle S. Ward, Keep An Eye Out For ISO Endorsements CG 22 94 And CG 22 95, San Diego County Bar Association blog
- Independent Agent magazine (Big “I” Virtual University), How the CG 22 94 Impacts Coverage for Contractors and Subcontractors (January 2018)
- Gary Grindle, Contractor’s General Liability Coverage Limitations: A Road Filled with Landmines, Insurance Journal (June 2009)
How these articles are written and checked. General information, not legal advice or an interpretation of your policy. Policy forms and endorsements control. Form numbers are © Insurance Services Office, Inc. and are cited for reference.