Who pays when a commissioning test fails and nothing is physically damaged?
By Siddansh Bohra, CEO, Rayon Insurance · Last reviewed
Only contractor professional liability. Builder’s risk and general liability both need physical loss or damage before they respond, and builder’s risk excludes liquidated damages even when a covered event caused the delay. A design or commissioning error that leaves a hall short of specification is a pure financial loss.
Does your policy give what your subcontract asks for? Send the insurance exhibit and your policy, and we send back one page showing where they disagree. Send your contract
Which policy looks at what?
| Policy | Needs physical damage? | Responds to a failed test with no damage? |
|---|---|---|
| Builder’s risk | Yes | No. It also excludes liquidated damages |
| General liability (CG 00 01) | Yes: bodily injury or property damage | No |
| Contractor professional liability | No | Possibly, if the failure comes from a professional service such as design or commissioning advice |
What counts as delegated design?
If your scope has you size, select or engineer part of the system (a cooling loop, a controls sequence, a busway layout) rather than only install to someone else’s drawings, you have taken on design. The AGC’s 2026 paper on data-center construction gives the example of a subcontractor with delegated design who miscalculates heat load: the loss is economic, and only professional liability addresses it [1]. The general liability form, by contrast, applies to bodily injury or property damage caused by an occurrence [2]. Which trades usually carry delegated design is in the trade-by-trade guide to data-center insurance.
Why are data-center jobs different?
Data-center contracts carry performance requirements on power, cooling and humidity, with liquidated damages when a hall is handed over late or short of specification [1]. Those damages can be large relative to a subcontract’s value, and no property policy pays them.
If a failed test does damage the works, a builder’s risk policy with a LEG defects clause still leaves out some of the cost of putting the defect right [3], as how LEG 2/96 and LEG 3/06 treat defective work explains.
What should I check?
- Whether your scope of work includes any design, engineering, sizing or commissioning advice.
- Whether you carry contractor professional liability at all, and whether it excludes faulty workmanship or means and methods so broadly that little is left [1]. If the project is wrapped, professional liability is one of the covers to check in what an OCIP or CCIP leaves you to carry.
- The liquidated-damages and consequential-damages clauses in the subcontract, and whether your liability is capped.
- Whether the generative AI exclusion CG 40 47 appears on any of your policies, since commissioning documents are often AI-assisted.
Sources
- AGC, Insurance Issues in Constructing Data Centers: A GC’s Perspective (2026)
- ISO CG 00 01 04 13, Commercial General Liability Coverage Form
- Carter Newell, Judicial consideration of LEG 2 and LEG 3
How these articles are written and checked. General information, not legal advice or an interpretation of your policy. Policy forms and endorsements control. Form numbers are © Insurance Services Office, Inc. and are cited for reference.