Who pays when a commissioning test fails and nothing is physically damaged?
By the Rayon research desk · Last reviewed
Only contractor professional liability. Builder’s risk and general liability both need physical loss or damage before they respond, and builder’s risk excludes liquidated damages even when a covered event caused the delay. A design or commissioning error that leaves a hall short of specification is a pure financial loss.
Which policy looks at what?
| Policy | Needs physical damage? | Responds to a failed test with no damage? |
|---|---|---|
| Builder’s risk | Yes | No. It also excludes liquidated damages |
| General liability (CG 00 01) | Yes: bodily injury or property damage | No |
| Contractor professional liability | No | Possibly, if the failure comes from a professional service such as design or commissioning advice |
What counts as delegated design?
If your scope has you size, select or engineer part of the system (a cooling loop, a controls sequence, a busway layout) rather than only install to someone else’s drawings, you have taken on design. The AGC’s 2026 paper on data-center construction gives the example of a subcontractor with delegated design who miscalculates heat load: the loss is economic, and only professional liability addresses it.
Why are data-center jobs different?
Data-center contracts carry performance requirements on power, cooling and humidity, with liquidated damages when a hall is handed over late or short of specification. Those damages can be large relative to a subcontract’s value, and no property policy pays them.
What should I check?
- Whether your scope of work includes any design, engineering, sizing or commissioning advice.
- Whether you carry contractor professional liability at all, and whether it excludes faulty workmanship or means and methods so broadly that little is left.
- The liquidated-damages and consequential-damages clauses in the subcontract, and whether your liability is capped.
- Whether the generative AI exclusion appears on any of your policies, since commissioning documents are often AI-assisted.
Sources
- AGC, Insurance Issues in Constructing Data Centers: A GC’s Perspective (2026)
- ISO CG 00 01 04 13, Commercial General Liability Coverage Form
- Carter Newell, Judicial consideration of LEG 2 and LEG 3
General information, not legal advice or an interpretation of your policy. Policy forms and endorsements control. Form numbers are © Insurance Services Office, Inc. and are cited for reference.