Skip to content

Why did the compliance vendor reject our certificate of insurance?

By , CEO, Rayon · Last reviewed

Usually because the certificate shows something the contract requires as missing, or the policy does not actually grant what was asked. The most common causes are missing completed-operations additional insured status, a holder or additional insured name that does not match the contract, a missing waiver of subrogation, limits below the requirement, and wording the insurer will not put on the form.

Want this checked on your own certificates? Bring 50 you have already sent and keep the findings. Book a walkthrough

What are the usual reasons?

What the reviewer saysWhat it usually meansThe fix
Additional insured not shown for completed operationsThe policy has CG 20 10 but not CG 20 37An endorsement, not a new certificate
Entity name does not matchThe contract names a different legal entity, or leaves out the owner or lenderCorrect the names; check the endorsement schedule too
Waiver of subrogation missingNo CG 24 04, or the party is not on its scheduleAn endorsement
Primary and non-contributory not statedThe policy lacks that wording, or the certificate omits itConfirm the endorsement exists, then restate it
Limits below requirementThe contract asks for more than the primary policy carriesOften met with an umbrella or excess policy; show it
Notice of cancellation wordingThe contract wants a promise the certificate cannot makeA separate endorsement, if the insurer offers one

Why can’t the agent just type what the contract says?

A certificate is a summary of the policy. The form itself says it is issued as a matter of information only, confers no rights on the certificate holder, and does not amend, extend or alter the coverage [1]. If the wording on the certificate goes beyond what the policy grants, the certificate is wrong and the owner is no better protected. What can properly go in the free-text box is covered in what an agency can put in the Description of Operations box.

So each rejection sorts into one of two kinds. Either the policy already grants what is asked and the certificate just needs to say so, or the policy does not grant it and an endorsement is needed first.

The endorsements behind the most common rejections each have their own article. Additional insured status during ongoing operations comes from CG 20 10 [2] and for completed operations from CG 20 37 [3], compared in CG 20 10 and CG 20 37: which additional insured endorsement a subcontract needs. The general liability waiver is CG 24 04, which waives the insurer’s right of recovery against the person or organization shown in its schedule [4]; see waiver of subrogation endorsements and where they are allowed. The other two rows are covered in what “primary and noncontributory” takes and why a certificate cannot promise 30 days’ notice of cancellation.

How do I stop it happening on the next job?

  • Send your broker the subcontract’s insurance exhibit before you sign, not after.
  • Ask for a list of what your policy grants automatically (for example blanket additional insured wording) and what must be requested each time.
  • Keep a note of the exact legal names of the owner, general contractor and lender for each project.
  • When a certificate is rejected, ask the reviewer for the specific requirement and section number.

Sources

  1. ACORD 25, Certificate of Liability Insurance (the notice printed at the top of the form)
  2. ISO CG 20 10 04 13, Additional Insured: Owners, Lessees or Contractors, Scheduled Person or Organization
  3. ISO CG 20 37 04 13, Additional Insured: Owners, Lessees or Contractors, Completed Operations
  4. ISO CG 24 04 05 09, Waiver of Transfer of Rights of Recovery Against Others to Us

How these articles are written and checked. General information, not legal advice or an interpretation of your policy. Policy forms and endorsements control. Form numbers are © Insurance Services Office, Inc. and are cited for reference.