If a leased robot injures one of your workers, who is liable?
By Siddansh Bohra, CEO, Rayon Insurance · Last reviewed
Your workers compensation policy pays the injured employee. In Illinois, workers comp is the employee's only remedy against you as the employer, though each state's statute has its own exceptions. The employee can still sue the robot's manufacturer, integrator or RaaS vendor. That company can then try to bring you back into the case through a contribution claim or through the indemnity clause you signed. How much of that comes back to you depends on state law and on the contract.
Running robots under a RaaS agreement or SOW? Send the contract and your certificate, and we come back with quotes for what it asks you to carry. Get a quote
Step 1: workers compensation pays, and usually bars a suit against you
In Illinois, the Workers' Compensation Act says no common law or statutory right to recover damages from the employer, its insurer or its broker is available to a covered employee for an injury sustained in the line of duty, other than the compensation the Act provides [1]. Section 11 makes that compensation "the measure of the responsibility" of the employer [2]. There is one narrow statutory exception: where a period of repose would bar compensation benefits, the employee keeps the right to bring a civil action against the employer [3].
This is the exclusive remedy rule. Its wording and exceptions are set by each state's statute, so if you run sites in more than one state, have counsel confirm how each one treats it.
NCCI's standard workers comp policy form is WC 00 00 00. Part One pays "the benefits required of you by the workers compensation law" [8]. Part Two, employers liability, is the part that matters later in this guide [8].
Step 2: the employee can sue the robot's vendor, integrator or maker
Exclusive remedy protects the employer. It does not protect anyone else. The Illinois Act says that where the injury was caused under circumstances creating a legal liability on "some person other than his employer," the employee can take legal proceedings against that person, whether or not the employer has paid compensation [1].
With a leased or RaaS robot, there are usually several such people: the company that made the robot, the integrator that built the cell, the RaaS vendor that leases and maintains it, and sometimes a software provider. A 2017 Swiss Re paper on robotics risk expected plaintiffs to sue widely to capture every potentially liable party, naming the manufacturer, the software developer, the robot owner or employer and others [11]. It described a fatal accident at an Alabama auto parts plant in which the plant and the robot's designer, manufacturer, marketer and seller were all named as defendants [11].
The employer gets something back from that suit. In Illinois, if the employee recovers from the third party, the employer is repaid the compensation it paid out of the recovery, less its pro rata share of costs and, absent another agreement, a 25% fee to the employee's attorney [1]. The employer has a lien on the recovery, and no settlement is valid without the written consent of both employer and employee, unless the employer has been fully indemnified or protected by court order [1]. If the employee does not sue in time, the employer can bring the action itself [1]. The standard workers comp policy gives the insurer your rights to recover its payments from anyone liable for the injury [8].
Step 3: the vendor can bring you back in
This is the third-party-over action. The vendor, sued by your employee, files a claim against you as the employer: for contribution because your own negligence contributed, or for indemnity under your contract.
Contribution in Illinois. In *Kotecki v. Cyclops Welding*, an employer was sued as a third-party defendant in a product liability case. The Illinois Supreme Court considered whether its contribution liability could exceed its liability under the Workers' Compensation Act [4]. The result, known as the Kotecki cap, limits the employer's contribution to the amount of its workers comp liability [5]. Illinois courts have since held that an employer can waive the cap by contract, usually inside an indemnity clause, and become liable for its full share [5].
Other states differ. New York, for example, bars a third party's contribution or indemnity claim against the employer unless the employee suffered a "grave injury" from a defined list (death, amputation or permanent loss of use of an arm, leg, hand or foot, paraplegia and others), or the employer expressly agreed to contribution or indemnification in a written contract entered into before the accident [6]. That written-contract exception is the same pattern as the Kotecki waiver: the contract you sign can undo the protection the statute gives you.
Step 4: which of your policies responds to the third-party-over claim
Two policies sit next to each other here, and each is written to stay out of the other's lane.
Employers liability (Part Two of WC 00 00 00). Part Two pays damages you must pay because of bodily injury to your employee, including damages "for which you are liable to a third party by reason of a claim or suit against you by that third party" for injury to your employee [8]. That is the third-party-over claim. But Part Two excludes "liability assumed under a contract," apart from a warranty that your work will be done in a workmanlike manner [8]. So a claim based on contribution may fall inside Part Two, subject to its limits and terms. A claim based only on the indemnity clause runs into the contract exclusion.
General liability (CG 00 01). Exclusion e. removes bodily injury to your own employee arising out of employment. It applies "whether the insured may be liable as an employer or in any other capacity" and to "any obligation to share damages with or repay someone else" [7]. So contribution claims sit outside the GL policy. The exclusion has one exception: it does not apply to liability assumed under an "insured contract" [7].
An "insured contract" includes the part of a contract relating to your business under which you assume the tort liability of another party to pay for bodily injury to a third person [7]. Exclusion b., contractual liability, has the same carve-back, and it also treats the indemnitee's defense costs as damages if you assumed them in the same insured contract [7]. Put simply, a properly drafted indemnity in a RaaS agreement may be picked up by your GL policy through the insured contract definition, subject to policy terms. A contribution claim falls to employers liability.
The Illinois gap. The Kotecki waiver does not fit neatly in either. According to a summary by Illinois defense firm BCM Law, the Illinois Supreme Court held in *Virginia Surety v. Northern Insurance* (2007) that a CGL policy did not cover liability above the Kotecki cap created by a contractual waiver, because the waiver was "a simple anticipatory waiver of an affirmative defense" and not the assumption of another party's tort liability [5]. The same article reports that NCCI drafted endorsement WC 12 03 06 to exclude from employers liability any agreement to waive the right to limit contribution to workers comp benefits [5]. If both are in play, the amount above the cap may have nowhere to go. Have counsel and your broker read the indemnity clause and both policies together.
Step 5: what the RaaS or integrator contract usually changes
Most of the outcome above depends on paper you signed before the robot arrived. Check these clauses:
- Indemnity. Does it say you indemnify the vendor for injuries to your own employees, "regardless of the vendor's negligence" or "to the fullest extent permitted by law"? Does it mention waiving workers comp immunity, Kotecki, or "any limitation under workers compensation law"?
- Insurance requirements. Does it ask for the vendor to be named additional insured on your GL, with a contractual liability or insured contract requirement? This is covered in additional insured status between robot vendors, integrators and operators.
- Waiver of subrogation. Endorsement WC 00 03 13 means your workers comp insurer will not enforce its right to recover from the named party, where a written contract requires it [9]. That gives up the recovery described in Step 2.
- Enforceability. Some indemnities are void by statute. Illinois, for instance, voids promises to indemnify someone for their own negligence in contracts for construction, alteration, repair or maintenance of a building or structure [12]. Whether a robot installation falls inside that statute is a legal question for counsel. It is not one to guess at.
The full list of clauses that move risk is in the RaaS agreement clauses that shift insurance risk.
What evidence will matter after an injury
Liability arguments after a robot injury often turn on who did what before go-live. OSHA's Technical Manual says it is the integrator's responsibility to complete and document a risk assessment before commissioning and give the results to the employer. Because the employer is responsible under OSHA for a safe workplace, it should require the integrator to provide that assessment and train employees on it [10]. The manual notes that many robot accidents happen during assembly, installation and testing, not normal operation. Its examples include a service company worker struck after cleaning a sensor while the robot was in automatic mode [10]. Swiss Re's paper also flags the question of whether the employer correctly followed the instructions for installing and operating the robot [11].
That last example runs in the other direction. If the vendor's own technician is hurt at your site, you are the third party. The technician's employer pays their comp, and the technician can sue you. Your GL employer's liability exclusion does not apply, because the technician is not your employee [7].
Keep the integrator's risk assessment, your training records, lockout procedures and the vendor's maintenance log in one place. They are what the insurers and lawyers will ask for first.
Where to start
We read the RaaS agreement or integrator SOW alongside your workers comp, employers liability and GL policies. That shows where an injury claim would land and whether the indemnity clause has created a gap, and we work alongside your current broker. Start with a deployment risk review.
Sources
- 820 ILCS 305/5, Illinois Workers' Compensation Act, Sec. 5 (Damages; third-party liability)
- 820 ILCS 305/11, Illinois Workers' Compensation Act, Sec. 11 (Measure of responsibility)
- 820 ILCS 305/1.2, Illinois Workers' Compensation Act, Sec. 1.2 (Permitted civil actions)
- Kotecki v. Cyclops Welding Corp., 146 Ill. 2d 155 (Ill. 1991), via vLex
- BCM Law, "Employers Liability Insurance: The Kotecki Coverage Exclusion and the Importance of a Reservation of Rights Letter" (June 2014)
- New York Workers' Compensation Law § 11
- ISO CG 00 01 04 13, Commercial General Liability Coverage Form
- NCCI WC 00 00 00 C, Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy
- NCCI WC 00 03 13, Waiver of Our Right to Recover From Others Endorsement (sample, with ISO CG 24 04)
- OSHA Technical Manual, Section IV, Chapter 4: Industrial Robot Systems and Industrial Robot System Safety
- Swiss Re, "The robots are here: what that means for insurers" (Trend Spotlight, 2017)
- 740 ILCS 35/1, Illinois Construction Contract Indemnification for Negligence Act
How these articles are written and checked. General information, not legal advice or an interpretation of your policy. Policy forms and endorsements control. Form numbers are © Insurance Services Office, Inc. and are cited for reference.